Yearbook-Archive: Vol 14 (1999)

Vol 14 (1999): Musikpsychologie – Wahrnehmung und Rezeption / Music Psychology – Perception and reception [*]

Volume 14 was edited by Klaus-Ernst Behne, Günter Kleinen und Helga de la Motte-Haber.

 

The printed volume was published by Hogrefe in 1999. The rights of use were reacquired by DGM and the contributions were republished here in 2020 as an OpenAccess publication for free, unrestricted use under the CC-BY 4.0 licence.

All contributions are available as searchable PDF files, have a DOI and are searchable in the PubPsych/PSYNDEX database. Contribution titles and abstracts are consistently given in German and English.

Titles and abstracts marked with [*] have been automatically translated from the original language with www.deepl.com.

Research Reports on Thematic Focus

Zu einer Theorie der Wirkungslosigkeit von (Hintergrund-)Musik On a theory of the ineffectiveness of (background) music [*]

Klaus-Ernst Behne
This text is based on a meta-analysis of 153 empirical studies investigating the effects of (background) music on non-musical activities. No significant effects of music could be proved for one third of these studies, with an increasing tendency in the last years. If non-significant results are interpreted as due to an ineffectiveness of music, it is necessary to consider all possible flaws of experimental methods and peculiarities of academic us­ age which could result in under- or overestimating the actual ineffectiveness of music. On this background it is presumed that nowadays in more than 50 % of everyday situations of listening to music we may expect no effects. The most important cause for this development is thought to be habitualization brought about by the over-all presence of music. The importance of lay psychological theories for the effects of music is shown through the example of a widely ignored study by Baker (1937). Finally, hypotheses and aspects of a theory of the ineffectiveness of (background) music are discussed.

100 Jahre musikalische Rezeptionsforschung. Ein Rückblick in die Zukunft 100 years of musical reception research. A look back into the future [*]

Heiner Gembris
This paper characterises the beginnings and current state of reception research and thus concerns the history of science. In particular, it addresses the central issues and methodological approaches of reception research. The author states that initially there were not only experimental and quantitative, but also empirically oriented qualitative and phenomenological research traditions. Although in the course of time, cognitivistic and experimental approaches prevailed, some examples from recent research demonstrate that the cognitivistic-experimental research often lacks practical relevance. The author suggests several ways to increase the practical relevance and ecological validity of musical reception research. Among those are the stronger consideration of the situational context of music listening and sensory-motor processes, an increased variety of research methods, a decrease of importance of the experimental paradigm, and a stronger link of research questions to everyday-life issues. Finally, it is argued that reception research requires a historical perspective in order to become aware of its own development and to reconstruct the time and culture specific changes in musical reception.

Entspannung durch Musik-Entspannungskassetten? Physiologische Befunde und ihre Aussage Relaxation through music relaxation tapes? Physiological findings and their statement [*]

Ulrike Karrer
During the last five years the market has been flooded with an immense number of various relaxation CDs. Their booklets promise a quick and easy route to relaxation. Some of them even promise to provide counsel­ ling in certain situations by music only or by a combination of text and music. Sceptical of these promises I investigated the actual effects of this "relaxation" music. An experimental group (n = 20, most of them experienced in music or instrumentalists) had to listen for 10 minutes to the CD "fresh and balanced in 15 minutes". They also could bring with them music from which they believed it would help them to relax. To test the effect of music in general a control group (n = 10) had to undergo the same procedure with­ out listening to any music. In addition to the 5 parameters blood oxygen saturation, pulse rate, pressure of oxygen and carbon dioxide in blood and skin temperature, which were taken every minute, blood pressure and body temperature were taken before and after a testing period to verify the state of activity of the body. Also, the persons were asked to fill in questionnaires about their musical preferences, personal details and attitudes towards CDs. As main result there is a significant difference between testing and control group. Notably a deeper state of immersion was reached, but also the relaxation in the second period of the control group was much better. According to these results, both a deeper relaxation and a better degree of immersion was reached without listening to music. One reason for this could be that most of the experimental group have a certain awareness of music and could have been distracted by the music rather than supported by it in relaxation.

Die Leistung der Sprache für ein Verständnis musi­kalischer Wahrnehmungsprozesse The power of language for an understanding of musical perception processes [*]

Günter Kleinen
Starting point is the hypothesis that a linguistic analysis of texts concerning the inner experience of music may give an essential contribution to an understanding of processes of music perception. An experiment was con­ ducted with 118 probands who had to lay down their spontaneous reactions on four examples of actual presented music pieces which differed in familiarity. A content analysis of the documented texts proofed the fact that every thinking in music (evaluation, interpretation, biographic context, daily experience) including the most important music metaphors (message, emotion, space, time), mediated by general image schemes, goes back to bodily sensations. Some categories of content analysis are chosen as examples and explained in respect to the characteristic bottom-up-processes. An analysis of contingencies shows the connections also in their statistical relevance so that the texture of connections may be brought into a systematic order and can be demonstrated in a figure. In consequence music cognition may be investigated adequately by qualitative methods especially by including the interpretation of language materials into the methodological repertoire of music psychology.

Hemisphärenasymmetrien bei der Beurteilung von Musik Hemispheric asymmetries in the assessment of music [*]

Reinhard Leichner, Nicole Bröscher
Music and emotions are interconnected in a close relationship. This close relationship can best be explained in terms of a theory in which the right hemisphere is the dominant one for the perception of music and emotions as also for the production of music and emotions. The right hemisphere is suited for events like music and emotions, because it is specialised to pro­ cess an event as a gestalt. The left hemisphere also plays an important part in perceiving music, because it is specialised for temporal aspects of music like rhythm and tempo. In the experiment subjects perceived the music either monaural (right, left) or binaural. We proceeded from the assumption that music perceived with the right ear will be processed in the left hemisphere and music perceived with the left ear will be processed in the right hemisphere. The pieces of music varied in two factors: Activation (activated vs. calm music) and valence (positive vs. negative music). The combination of the two factors resulted in four types of music: positive­ activated, negative-activated, positive-calm, negative-calm. The quality of the four types of music were tested with different scales and in addition to that the influence of the music on behavioural tendencies which are one component of emotions was also registered. According to the hypothesis the hemispheric asymmetry has an effect on the perception of music but not on the behavioural tendencies. The behavioural tendencies are stronger effected from the emotion caused by music. lt showed that the right hemisphere is better suited to perceive the valence of music than the left hemisphere. This result supports the theory that the right hemisphere is the dominant one for the perception of music. Music perceived with the left, and especially with both hemispheres, will be judge to be faster in tempo than perceived with the right hemisphere. lt seems that the left hemisphere, and especially the working together of the two hemispheres, is better suited to estimate the actual tempo of music than the right hemisphere. According to the hypothesis the hemispheric asymmetry does not have an effect on behavioural tendencies.

Research Reports

Factors and Abilities Influencing the Development of Musical Performance Faktoren und Fähigkeiten, die die Entwicklung der musikalischen Darbietung beeinflussen [*]

Gary McPherson
This paper reports on a three year longitudinal study which examined the development of five distinct types of musical performance. High School instrumentalists were administered tests to measure their capacity to perform a repertoire of rehearsed music, sight-read, play by ear, play from memory and improvise. Additional data concerning a range of variables thought to influence the development of these skills were obtained in face­ to-face interviews using a structured questionnaire, and a content analysis of reflective comments made by students as they completed each of the measures. Path analysis was used to test a theoretical model designed to encapsulate the flow of influences theorised to exist between the five types of musical performance and four factors derived from variables thought to influence their development (see McPherson, Bailey & Sinclair, 1997a). Tue study has implications for instrumental teaching which range from a re-evaluation of teaching practices that are restricted to the refinement of performance repertoire and technique, to guidance in the aural and creative styles of performance and cognitive strategies which this study shows may exert a positive influence on the development of overall performance ability.

Expression and Meaning in Tasol: Hedonic Effects of Development vs. Chance in Resolved and Unresolved Aural Episodes Ausdruck und Bedeutung in Tasol: Hedonische Effekte von Entwicklung vs. Zufall in gelösten und ungelösten Gehörschäden [*]

Vladimir Koneĉni
Reported here is a detailed experimental examination of the individual and combined effects of the structural elements of an entire and intact quasi-musical performance piece. The playwright of Tasol and the re­ searcher were the same person. The study was especially concerned with the hedonic impact of classical vs. aleatory components of the piece and of its mode of presentation. Four samples of subjects in Lahti, Amsterdam, Rotterdam, and San Diego (N = 184), which were classified into two sub­ samples on the basis of aesthetic experience, rated, in small groups, the eight research versions of the original piece ( a 2 x 2 x 2 between-subjects design), that were presented on black & white videotapes. The orthogonal factors represented the three constituent elements of the piece, with the first mentioned being the original: (a) Development + Climax vs. Chance; (b) "Death" vs. "No Death" of the players; and (c) Respiratory/Vocal (sneeze, laugh, cough) vs. Instrumental (three toy instruments) performance of the aural events. On the key psycho-aesthetic dimensions of pleasingness and interestingness, quasi-Tasol, the research version closest to the original, was rated by far the highest of the eight. This was true for both sub-samples on the interestingness scale, but only for the aesthetically experienced sub-sample on pleasingness and a number of other scales that helped explain the hedonic advantage of the original piece. These and auxiliary results indirectly explain the failure of aleatory and stochastic works to appeal to all but the most rarefied audiences.

Close-Up

Die Realität der Phantasiewelt: ,,Winzig" von Manos Tsangaris The reality of the fantasy world: "Winzig" by Manos Tsangaris [*]

Helga de la Motte-Haber

Spot

Verkörperlichung des Klangs. ,,Dominus Vobiscum" von Gunter Demnig Embodiment of the sound. "Dominus Vobiscum" by Gunter Demnig [*]

Helga de la Motte-Haber

Reviews
The contributions in this section are available as a Collective PDF

I. Deliege & J. Sloboda (Hrsg.): Musical Beginnings

Helga de la Motte-Haber

H. Fastl, S. Kuwano & A. Schick (Hrsg.): Recent Trends in Hearing Research

Wolfgang Auhagen

M. Fischer: Der Intonationstest

Reinhard Kopiez

J. T. Fraser & L. Rowell (Hrsg.): Time and Process

Helga de la Motte-Haber

H. H. Goll: Special Educational Music Therapy

Heiner Gembris

D. J. Hargreaves & A. C. North (Hrsg.): The Social Psychology of Music

Klaus-Ernst Behne

S. Gruber: Das Konsumentenverhalten bei Independent-Tonträgern

Christoph Metzger

H. Jørgensen & A. C. Lehmann (Hrsg.): Does practice make perfect?

Jan Hemming

D. de la Motte & W. Schulze (Hrsg.): Zeit in der Musik - Musik in der Zeit

Oliver Schwab-Felisch

L. Langeheine: Üben mit Köpfchen

Gunter Kreutz

M. Leman (Hrsg.): Music, Gestalt, and Computing

Günter Kleinen

P. J. Martin: Sounds and Society

Hans Neuhoff

U. Mattusch: Verarbeitung und Repräsentation musikalischer Struk­turen

Martha Brech

A. Schick & M. Klatte (Hrsg.): Contributions to Psychological Acoustics

Wolfgang Auhagen

Th. Vogel (Hrsg.): Über das Hören. Einem Phänomen auf der Spur

Christoph Metzger

Chr. Wagner (Hrsg.): Medizinische Probleme bei Instrumentalisten

Isolde Vetter

Reports
The contributions in this section are available as a Collective PDF

MultiMedia in der empirischen Musikrezeptionsforschung

Renate Müller

Third Triennial ESCOM Conference in Uppsala, Schweden, 1997

Günter Kleinen

Jahrestagung der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Musikpsychologie in Rostock, 1997

Ernst Dombrowski

Music and Emotion, Genf 1998

Gunter Kreutz